Can a rooflight or skylight be replaced in the same opening?
Usually yes, and it is much the cheapest way to renew a rooflight. The structural opening, the trimming and generally the kerb are already there, so a unit of the same size goes back into work that has already been done. What decides how straightforward it is comes down to the kerb, the covering and whether anything underneath has taken water.
Why it is worth aiming for
Because the expensive parts already exist.
Cutting an opening, trimming the structure and building a kerb are the substantial items on a new installation, and a like for like replacement skips all three.
Where the money goes is on how much does it cost to replace a rooflight.
What has to match
The kerb dimensions rather than the old unit.
A replacement is ordered to the external dimensions of the upstand it will sit on, which is what a survey measures rather than the glass or the old frame.
Measuring for it
Across the kerb, in both directions, and diagonally.
The diagonals matter as much as the sides, because a kerb out of square by a small amount changes what will sit on it properly.
Where the kerb is not square
Corrected rather than packed. A rigid frame on an unsquare perimeter leaves a gap at one corner, and packing and sealing that is exactly how the last one came to leak.
Where the kerb is too low
Rebuilt, and it is worth the day.
An upstand shorter than it should be will keep causing the same problem under a new rooflight as it did under the old one.
The heights are on how high should a rooflight kerb be.
Where the kerb is not insulated
The opportunity worth taking. With the unit off, insulating the upstand properly is quick and cheap, and it deals with the winter condensation that gets blamed on the glass.
The covering around it
Where the age of the roof shows.
Dressing a new detail into a sound covering is straightforward. Doing it into a brittle felt at the end of its life is a patch on a roof that wants replacing.

Doing it with a roof recovering
The cheapest moment for both. Where a flat roof is due to be recovered, replacing the rooflight at the same time shares the access, the covering work and the kerb detail entirely.
On a pitched roof
The opening and often the flashing survive.
Where the same size code goes back in, the trimming is there and parts of the flashing may be reusable, and the courses go back to the same lines.
That is on can a VELUX be replaced like for like.
Whether the flashing is reused
A judgement on the day. Sound, undisturbed and matched to the same frame size, parts can stay. Patched, dressed over, or a different generation, it is renewed.
What is found underneath
The variable that cannot be priced from the ground.
A long standing leak will have got into a kerb or a trimmer, and that timber is cut out and replaced before anything new goes on.
What that involves is on what happens if the timber underneath has rotted.
Changing the product in the same opening
Frequently possible and worth considering. A dome can become flat glass, a fixed unit can become an opening one, and a single glazed unit can become a modern sealed one, all on the same kerb.
The dome case is on can a dome rooflight be replaced with glass.
Where the frame depth differs
The detail that catches a straight swap.
Modern units are often deeper than older ones, so the new frame can sit differently relative to the covering and the reveal even at the same plan size.
The reveal inside
Expect to make it good. Even a perfect match disturbs the plaster line, so a replacement is a roofing job followed by a small plastering and decorating one.

Splaying it while it is open
Worth doing if it is not already.
Angling the internal faces of the kerb spreads the light noticeably, and it is easy while the reveal is being made good anyway.
Upgrading the glass
The decision to make at order. Solar control, a better coating or a warm edge spacer cost little at the point of ordering and cannot be added afterwards.
What each does is on what is solar control glass.
What has to be notified
Generally the thermal requirement.
A replacement rooflight has to meet a stated performance even in the same opening, and that is checked and certificated.
That is on does replacing a rooflight need building regulations.
How long it takes
A day on a straightforward swap. Plus the lead time on the unit, and plus the plastering afterwards, which is what actually decides when the room is finished.
That is on how long does a rooflight replacement take.
Doing several at once
Where the saving is largest. Access and protection happen once, so three replacements on one visit cost considerably less than three separate jobs.
What is done with the old unit
Taken away and recycled where it can be.
Aluminium frames go for metal recycling and sealed units go to a glass processor, and it is worth confirming that rather than assuming.
Protecting the room below
Done first, before anything is lifted. A replacement usually happens in a finished room, so the floor is sheeted, furniture is moved and covered, and the opening is worked on with the room protected beneath it.
It matters more here than on a new installation, where the room is often still a building site.
How we measure it on a replacement
We measure the kerb and its diagonals rather than the old unit, and we say when an upstand should be rebuilt rather than reused, because a new rooflight on an old fault fails the same way.
The whole picture is on the replacing a failed or misted rooflight page.
Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.