Can a dome rooflight or skylight be replaced with glass?
Yes, and it is one of the most worthwhile changes you can make to an older flat roof. A glass unit on the existing kerb is clearer, warmer, quieter in rain and dramatically better looking than a yellowed polycarbonate dome. What has to be checked is the kerb, because a dome and a flat glass unit ask slightly different things of it.
Why domes were used
Because the shape sheds water.
A curved polymer sheet drains by its own form regardless of what the roof beneath it is doing, which made it forgiving on flat roofs with uncertain falls.
What has gone wrong with yours
Ultraviolet, over decades.
Polycarbonate and acrylic yellow and craze under sunlight, so an old dome is cloudy, brittle and passing far less light than it did.
Whether it is safe
Worth thinking about.
An old brittle dome is fragile, and nobody should be treating any rooflight as a stepping point, but an aged polymer one is genuinely weak.
What glass gives you
Clarity that does not degrade.
Glass does not yellow, does not craze and does not lose light with age, so the improvement is permanent rather than a refresh.
What else it gives you
Warmth, and a great deal of it.
An old single skin or twin wall dome performs poorly thermally, and a modern sealed unit with a low emissivity coating is a substantial step.
The comparison is on will a new rooflight be warmer.
Rain noise
A difference people notice immediately.
A polymer dome over a room is considerably louder in heavy rain than a glass unit, which matters over a bedroom or a quiet room.
That is on are electric rooflights noisy.
How it looks
The change that surprises people most.
A flush glass unit reads as a quiet rectangle in the roof where a dome reads as a bubble standing on it, and from an upstairs window that is a large difference.

The kerb
The thing that decides the job.
Its height, its squareness and whether it is insulated are all assessed, and a kerb built for a dome is not automatically right for a glass unit.
The requirements are on how high should a rooflight kerb be.
Why the fall matters more
Because a flat pane does not shed by shape.
A dome drains whatever the roof does. A flat glass unit relies on the roof having a fall, so a genuinely level roof needs looking at first.
The falls are on what is the minimum fall for a flat roof with a rooflight.
Where the fall is inadequate
Two answers. Either the roof is re laid with a fall, which is a larger job, or a unit designed to work on a very shallow fall is specified, and the second is usually right.
The weight
Considerably more, and it is worth checking.
A sealed glass unit weighs a great deal more than a polymer dome, so the kerb and the deck around it are looked at rather than assumed.
Squaring the kerb
More important than it was. A dome frame will tolerate a kerb slightly out of square. A rigid glass unit will not, and a gap packed and sealed at one corner is a future leak.
Insulating it while it is off
The opportunity worth taking. An old dome kerb is frequently uninsulated, and with the unit off, insulating it properly is quick and deals with winter condensation permanently.
Matching the size
Measured off the kerb rather than the dome.
Replacement units are ordered to the external dimensions of the upstand, which is what a survey takes.
That is on can a rooflight be replaced in the same opening.
An opening version
Worth considering while you are changing it.
If the room is a kitchen or a shower room, an opening glass unit does something the dome never did, and it is decided at order or not at all.
That is on is an opening rooflight worth it on a flat roof.

Solar control
Worth specifying on a south facing roof.
Clear glass admits far more solar energy than a yellowed dome did, so a room that was never too hot can become so if the glass is specified carelessly.
What it does is on what is solar control glass.
Safety glass overhead
Specified as a matter of course. Glass above a room is made so it cannot fall in pieces, which normally means a laminated inner pane.
The covering around it
Where the age of the roof shows.
An old dome usually sits in an old covering, and if the felt is near the end of its life the sensible move is to do both together.
What has to be notified
The thermal requirement. A replacement rooflight has to meet a stated performance, which a modern glass unit does comfortably and an old dome did not.
That is on does replacing a rooflight need building regulations.
Twin and triple skin domes
Worth distinguishing from a single skin one.
A later multi skin dome performs considerably better than an old single sheet, so a house may have something less dated than it looks from below.
The age and the yellowing tell you more than the description does.
Where a dome is still the right answer
A genuinely level roof over an unheated space.
On a garage or a store with no fall worth speaking of, a modern dome sheds water by its shape and asks nothing of the roof beneath it.
Getting a glass unit onto the roof
The practical difference on the day.
A dome is carried up by one person. A sealed glass unit of the same size is a two or three person lift and may need equipment, and that is priced in.
What we check on a replacement
We check the fall and the kerb before quoting a glass unit onto a dome kerb, because those two are the only reasons this straightforward upgrade ever goes wrong.
The whole picture is on the replacing a failed or misted rooflight page.
Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.