In a room a rooflight cannot reach, a sun tunnel is not better, it is the only option. Where both are genuinely possible, a rooflight gives more light, a view of the sky and a sense of outside that a diffuser cannot. What a tunnel offers instead is a fraction of the cost, a fraction of the disruption and no structural work at all.
Where a rooflight or skylight cannot go
A room that is not under the roof.
A ground floor hallway with a bedroom above it, or an internal room with another room over it, has no route for a rooflight and a tube is the answer.
Where a tunnel cannot go
A room with no void above it.
A vaulted ceiling or a converted loft has nothing for a tube to run through, and a rooflight straight through the slope is the product.
What a ceiling has to allow is on can a sun tunnel be fitted to any ceiling.
Where both are possible
A top floor room under a loft.
A bathroom, a landing or a bedroom directly beneath a pitched roof can have either, and that is where the comparison is real.
Light: the rooflight wins
By a wide margin.
Even a small roof window has a far larger aperture than a tunnel diffuser, and none of its light is lost travelling down a tube.
The view
The thing a tunnel simply does not offer.
A rooflight gives sky, cloud, rain on the glass and a sense of the weather, and a diffuser gives even light and nothing else.
Ventilation
Another thing only a rooflight does.
An opening roof window airs a room from its highest point, and a sealed tube contributes nothing at all to ventilation.
What that is worth is on is an opening rooflight worth it on a flat roof.
Cost: the tunnel wins
By a multiple, not a margin.
No structural opening, no reveal, no plastering and a much smaller unit put a sun tunnel in a completely different bracket.
The lines are on how much does a sun tunnel cost.

Disruption: the tunnel wins
Half a day against a week.
A hole saw and a diffuser against a trimmed opening, a plastered reveal and a room that has to dry before it can be decorated.
Heat loss: the tunnel wins
A much smaller aperture.
Any rooflight is a larger area of worse insulation than the ceiling it replaced, and a small tunnel is a far smaller intervention.
The figures are on are sun tunnels energy efficient.
Overheating: the tunnel wins
Nothing to overheat with.
A small diffuse aperture contributes negligible solar gain, where a south facing rooflight can make a small room uncomfortable in July.
Planning: the tunnel wins
A far lower profile.
On a designated or a visible slope, a small flashed head is a much easier proposition than a rooflight, and it occasionally unlocks a position.
The tests are on do sun tunnels need planning permission.
Value added to the house
The rooflight, generally.
A daylit room with a view of the sky reads as a better room to a buyer, and a diffuser reads as a light fitting.
What the room actually is
The question that decides it.
A bathroom, a landing, a cloakroom or a utility wants light and does not want a view. A bedroom or a study wants both.
Where the tunnel is clearly right
A small internal room with no other option.
A windowless cloakroom or an inner hallway is transformed by a tunnel and could not have a rooflight at all.
Where the rooflight is clearly right
A room somebody spends time in.
A bedroom, a study or a kitchen under a roof benefits from the light, the view and the ventilation, and the extra cost buys all three.

Where it is a genuine toss up
A top floor bathroom.
Both work, the rooflight gives more and needs obscured glass and an opening decision, and the tunnel gives privacy and simplicity for far less.
The room specifics are on can a sun tunnel go in a bathroom.
Two tunnels against one rooflight
Worth considering on a long room.
Two diffusers spread across a hallway light it more evenly than a single rooflight at one end, and still for less.
Having both
Common in one house.
A rooflight over the room somebody uses and tunnels over the landing and the bathroom is a sensible allocation of a budget.
What people regret
Rarely the tunnel.
The commonest regret we hear is a tunnel that was undersized or that was routed with a bend, rather than the decision to fit one.
Sizing is on what size sun tunnel do I need.
What decides it in the end
Whether the room deserves a view. If somebody will stand there and look up, fit a rooflight. If they will walk through it and want to see, fit a tunnel.
Against better electric lighting
The third option nobody mentions. A well designed lighting scheme in a windowless room is cheaper than either, and it does not change through the day or tell you what the weather is doing.
Which is precisely what people are buying when they ask for daylight.
Against a borrowed light
An internal glazed panel. A glazed panel over a door or in a partition borrows light from an adjacent room, and it works where that room has plenty to spare and privacy does not matter.
What we say on a sun tunnel
We say when a room deserves a rooflight rather than a tunnel, because the cheaper product is the right answer in a great many rooms and the wrong one in a bedroom.
The whole picture is on the sun tunnel installation page.
Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.