Yes, on two counts. The aperture is small, so the heat loss through it is modest compared with any rooflight, and the room is lit by daylight rather than by a lamp for much of the day. What decides whether that holds up is the detailing: an uninsulated tube through a cold loft loses far more than the diffuser area suggests.
How a rooflight loses heat
The general mechanism is on does a rooflight lose more heat than a window.
What follows is what a small aperture on a long tube does differently.
The aperture is small
The first reason it performs well.
A tunnel diffuser is a fraction of the area of even a small rooflight, so whatever its performance per square metre, the total loss is modest.
The tube is a buffer
The second reason. A sealed tube full of still air between the room and the roof is itself an insulating layer, so the assembly performs better than a single glazed dome would suggest.
Where the losses actually are
Around the tube, not through it. The big losses on a poorly fitted tunnel are air leaking past the diffuser into the loft and heat conducting along an uninsulated tube.
Sealing at the ceiling
The single most valuable detail. A gap where the tube passes the ceiling is a direct path from a warm room to a cold loft, and it loses more than the glazing ever will.
Insulating the tube
The second most valuable. A tube insulated where it crosses the loft stops the assembly acting as a heat path and stops it running with condensation.
Why is on do sun tunnels cause condensation.
The double diffuser
Available, and worth having. Some products offer a second diffuser or a sealed unit at the ceiling, which traps a further layer of air and improves the figure noticeably.

The insulated tube option
Also worth asking about. Manufacturers offer insulated tube sections for exactly this, which is a better answer than wrapping a standard tube on site.
What the figure looks like
Read for the whole assembly. A manufacturer figure covers the unit as a system, and it is the number to compare rather than any figure for the dome alone.
What that means is on what U value should a rooflight have.
The lighting saving
Real, and modest in money. A hallway or a bathroom lit by a lamp all day now needs none for most of it, which is a genuine reduction in a small way.
Where the saving is largest
A room with the light on constantly.
An internal bathroom or a windowless landing where the light was left on all day is where a tunnel produces a measurable change.
Where it is smallest
A room used briefly.
A cloakroom used twice a day was never costing much to light, so the case there is comfort rather than economy.
Solar gain
Negligible in either direction.
The aperture is small and the diffuser scatters what arrives, so a tunnel neither overheats a room in summer nor contributes usefully in winter.
Against a rooflight thermally
A tunnel wins comfortably.
Any rooflight is a larger area of worse insulation than the ceiling it replaced, and a small tunnel is a much smaller intervention in the envelope.
The comparison is on is a sun tunnel better than a small rooflight.
Against the ceiling it replaced
A small loss, honestly.
An insulated ceiling is better than any glazed aperture, so a tunnel is a modest thermal cost paid for a large gain in daylight.

What the regulations ask
Less than for a rooflight.
The glazed area is very small, so the limits on total glazed area are barely engaged, and the thermal requirement is straightforward.
What applies is on do sun tunnels need building regulations.
Whether it affects an EPC
Very little on its own.
A small aperture is a minor element in an assessment, and the lighting benefit is not the kind of thing an EPC captures well.
The general point is on does a rooflight affect an EPC.
The wellbeing argument
Not measurable, and it is why people buy them.
Daylight in a room that has never had any changes how it is used far more than the energy figures change a bill.
What we would insist on
The seal and the insulation.
Those two take fifteen minutes on the day and they decide whether a tunnel is an efficient addition or a hole in the ceiling.
Where the loft is a warm one
A different situation, and simpler.
Where the insulation follows the rafters rather than the ceiling, the loft is within the heated envelope, so the tube is not crossing cold air at all.
The insulation and the seal then matter for airtightness rather than for condensation.
Where the tunnel serves an unheated space
A garage or a store.
There is no thermal envelope to speak of, so the detailing is simpler and the tunnel is a light source rather than an element in a calculation.
What it costs to do properly
Almost nothing on the day.
An insulated sleeve and a sealant joint are small items against the kit, and they are the difference between a good installation and a mediocre one.
Where it sits is on how much does a sun tunnel cost.
What we seal
We seal at the ceiling and insulate the tube on every installation, because they cost nothing on the day and they are the difference between a tunnel that helps and one that quietly costs.
The whole picture is on the sun tunnel installation page.
Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.