Salt damage to a coastal frame, and when the frame is finished
On a coastal roof the glass usually outlasts everything holding it. This page is about the assessment that decides whether a frame is tired or finished, because those are two different answers with two very different costs.
Why salt attacks metal, and what specification resists it, are covered on the stainless fixings and coating life pages. This one is the condemnation decision.
Cosmetic, serviceable, structural
Every finding on a corroded frame falls into one of three categories, and sorting them is the whole assessment.
Cosmetic. It looks poor and it is not doing harm. A chalked coating, staining, discolouration. The frame will outlive the appearance by decades.
Serviceable. A component has degraded and can be replaced. Gaskets, fixings, a corroded trim, a seized catch.
Structural. The frame section itself has lost material or integrity. This is the category that ends a unit.
Almost everything people point at is in the first two.
What to look at, in order
- The horizontal upward facing surfaces, which collect salt and take the most ultraviolet.
- Every fixing position, which is where a coating was breached.
- Cut edges and any site drilled hole.
- Corners and welded or mechanical joints in the frame.
- Any point where two different metals meet.
- The underside and the concealed faces, which nobody looks at and which never get rinsed.
The last one is the one that matters most. A frame can look acceptable from below and from above and be substantially worse in the sheltered detail where rain never reaches and salt has been accumulating for twenty years.
The forms of corrosion you will see
| What it looks like | What it is | Category |
|---|---|---|
| Matt, faded, powder on a finger | Chalking of the coating | Cosmetic |
| Fine threads creeping from a scratch | Filiform corrosion under the coating | Serviceable early, structural if left |
| White powdery bloom, localised | Pitting corrosion of the aluminium | Depends on depth |
| Blistering, coating lifting | Corrosion product forming beneath | Investigate. Something is happening underneath |
| Corrosion concentrated at a joint | Galvanic, between two metals | Serviceable if caught, structural if not |
| Section visibly thinned or perforated | Advanced loss of material | Structural. The frame is finished |
Why aluminium corrodes differently from steel
It matters for the assessment because the two look nothing alike.
Steel rusts generally, over whole surfaces, in an obvious brown that everybody recognises. Aluminium does not. It forms a tough oxide layer that protects it, and where that layer is broken locally, the corrosion goes downward as a pit rather than outward as a sheet.
So aluminium corrosion is white or grey rather than brown, it is localised rather than general, and it is deep rather than broad. A frame with a scatter of small white blooms may have lost more section than a steel component that looks far worse.

Pitting, and why depth is the question
A pit is a small hole going into the metal, and what matters is how far in it goes rather than how wide it is on the surface.
Shallow pitting on the face of a substantial section is cosmetic. Deep pitting in a thin wall, or a run of pits along a line, is a loss of section in a place that may be carrying load.
Assessing that means cleaning the area and looking properly rather than glancing. Where a pit can be felt with a probe as a hole rather than a mark, it is in the serious category.
The bimetallic joint
Where corrosion concentrates on a coastal roof, and it is worth checking specifically.
Where two different metals meet with a salt film between them, the less noble one corrodes preferentially. On a rooflight that is usually the aluminium frame against a steel fixing or a plated trim, and the aluminium is the part that goes.
The signature is corrosion clearly worst at and radiating from a joint, with the frame elsewhere in reasonable condition. Where that is caught early it is a serviceable problem: replace the offending component with a compatible one and isolate the joint. Left for a decade it becomes structural at that point.
Thermal breaks
A frame specific failure worth knowing about.
An aluminium rooflight frame has a low conductivity section built into the profile, joining the inner and outer aluminium sections. It is polymer, it is structural, and it is doing thermal work.
Where corrosion has worked into the joint between the aluminium and the thermal break, or where the polymer has degraded, the frame can lose stiffness in a way that is not visible as corrosion. The tell is a frame that has gone slightly out of true, or a unit that no longer seals evenly along one edge.
That is a structural finding and it is not repairable in place.
Six questions that decide it
The assessment comes down to these, and any one answered badly enough finishes a frame.
- Has the section lost material anywhere it is carrying load?
- Is the frame still true, or has it distorted?
- Do the fixings still have sound metal to hold into?
- Is the thermal break intact?
- Can the unit still be made to seal evenly along its whole edge?
- Are replacement components available for what is serviceable?

The fixings question is frequently the answer
In practice, on the coastal replacements we do, the fixings decide more jobs than the frame does.
Where heads shear on removal, where threads have corroded away in the timber below, where a fixing turns endlessly, the unit has to come off carefully and the fixings have to be drilled out. That is a morning of work regardless of what happens next.
Once the unit is off and the fixing positions are being made good, the marginal cost of a new unit against reworking the old one narrows considerably. So a frame that is technically recoverable is frequently not worth recovering.
What can be done to a tired frame
Where the assessment says serviceable rather than structural, a good deal is available.
Gaskets replace. Fixings replace, upgraded to A4 stainless and isolated. Trims and cappings replace, in marine grade coating. Handles, catches and actuators replace. And the coating can be repainted in place, with the caveats that it is a cosmetic remedy and needs proper preparation.
A unit with sound glass, a sound frame and all of that done is genuinely good for another long period, and it is a fraction of the cost of replacement.
What cannot
Lost section cannot be restored. A distorted frame cannot be pulled true and expected to stay. A degraded thermal break cannot be replaced in situ. And a frame that no longer holds a fixing has nothing to build on.
Any one of those is the end of a frame, and saying so early is more useful than a repair that fails in two years.
How exposure changes the timescale
The same frame in two positions a few miles apart ages very differently, and it is worth knowing what drives it.
A seafront property takes salt aerosol continuously, and a horizontal surface on its roof holds a damp salty film for most of the year. A property a couple of miles inland behind a town takes considerably less. And on the open scarp above the plain, exposure puts a site back into the coastal category despite the distance.
Which means age alone is a poor guide. A fifteen year old frame on the seafront at Goring may be in worse condition than a thirty year old one at Storrington, and the assessment is made on what is in front of you rather than on the date.
What an owner can check from the ground
A useful amount, and none of it needs a ladder.
Run a finger along any reachable part of the frame and see whether powder comes off, which is chalking. Look for staining running down from any fixing position, which is corrosion at a breach. Look at the trims, which are horizontal and fail first. And from inside, look at whether the unit still seals evenly all round, and whether any part of the frame has visibly moved.
None of that is a survey and it will tell you whether you are looking at a cosmetic problem or something worth having looked at properly.

Where the honest answer is uncertainty
Some of this cannot be established until the unit is off, and we say so at quotation rather than after.
The concealed faces, the condition of the fixing positions, and whether heads will shear are all unknown from either side. On a coastal replacement we quote the known work and name the unknowns rather than pricing an assumption.
A quotation that pretends to certainty about a twenty five year old coastal frame nobody has taken off is a quotation that will move.
Timber frames on the coast
A different set of failures and the same three categories.
Timber does not corrode; it decays, and it does so where the finish has failed and water has reached it. The place is almost always the bottom of the sash, which is where water runs to and where condensation collects.
Surface weathering is cosmetic and refinishable. Softness that a probe enters is decay, and decay in the bottom rail of a sash carrying ironmongery is structural. The advantage timber has is that it is repairable by splicing in sound material, which aluminium is not.
Documenting the condition
An assessment is worth recording, because it is the baseline against which the next one is read.
Photographs of each area of concern, dated, with a note of what category it was put in. In five years the useful question is not whether there is pitting but whether it has got worse, and nobody can answer that from memory.
On a coastal property with several units, that record also tells you which is deteriorating fastest and therefore which to deal with first. It costs ten minutes at a survey and it converts a series of opinions into a trend.
How we sort it
We sort every finding into cosmetic, serviceable or structural before saying anything about replacement, because most of what looks alarming is in the first category. We check the concealed faces and the fixing positions rather than the visible surfaces. We name the unknowns at quotation on any coastal unit, and we say plainly when a frame is worth servicing rather than replacing, even though that is the smaller job.
Where the answer is that a frame has years left in it, we will say so and quote the service work rather than the replacement, because a customer who is told the truth about a frame at year fifteen is a customer who comes back at year twenty five.
A chalked frame looks finished and rarely is. A frame that no longer holds a fixing looks fine and is.
Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.