Can a rooflight or skylight be a smoke vent?
Only if it is a certified smoke ventilation unit. A comfort opener that happens to be large is not a smoke vent, however wide it opens. A smoke vent is a tested product with a stated performance, driven from a dedicated control panel with battery backup and monitored wiring, and it is specified by a fire engineer or a designer rather than chosen from a catalogue.
What a smoke vent is for
Clearing a route, not cooling a room.
Smoke ventilation exists to keep an escape route usable and to give a fire service somewhere for heat and smoke to go, and it is part of a fire strategy rather than a comfort feature.
Where the requirement comes from
The fire safety design for the building.
Common stairs in blocks of flats and certain other buildings need smoke ventilation, and the requirement is set out in the design rather than decided on site.
Why a comfort opener does not qualify
Because nothing about it has been tested for the job.
A ventilation actuator has no tested opening time, no certified performance in heat, no monitored wiring and no guaranteed supply in a fire.
Each of those is part of what a certified unit provides.
Opening time
One of the tested characteristics. A smoke vent has to reach its open position within a stated period from the signal, and that is a property of the unit and its actuator rather than an assumption.
Behaviour in heat
The distinction that matters most. A vent has to keep working while hot smoke passes through it, and the components are tested for that where a comfort actuator simply is not.
The control panel
Dedicated, and nothing like a rooflight controller.
A smoke ventilation panel monitors its wiring, holds a battery backup, and takes inputs from detectors and from manual call points at the required locations.
Battery backup
Required rather than optional. The vent has to operate when the mains supply has gone, which is precisely the situation a fire creates.
Why that matters generally is on can an electric rooflight be opened in a power cut.

Monitored wiring
The part that makes it a system.
The panel checks its own circuits continuously and reports a fault, so a broken cable is known about before it matters rather than discovered afterwards.
Manual call points
Positioned by the fire strategy. A fire service override at an agreed location lets the vent be operated on arrival, and where those go is part of the design.
The free area
The number the design works to. A vent is specified by the geometric or aerodynamic free area it provides when open, which is a tested figure rather than the size of the hole.
Aerodynamic against geometric
Two figures and they are not the same.
Geometric free area is the measured opening. Aerodynamic free area accounts for how efficiently air actually passes through it, and it is the smaller and more useful number.
Where this comes up in a house
Rarely, and it does happen.
A single dwelling almost never needs smoke ventilation, and a converted building, a house in multiple occupation or a block of flats can.
A stairwell rooflight in a block
The commonest case by far. An automatic opening vent at the head of a common stair is standard provision in many blocks, and replacing one is a specialist job rather than a rooflight swap.
Replacing an existing vent
Like for like, and certified. Where a block already has one, the replacement has to meet the same specification, and the panel and wiring are part of that conversation.
Who specifies it
A fire engineer, an architect, or building control.
The performance required comes from the fire strategy for the building, and a rooflight supplier meets a specification rather than writing one.

Escape is a different requirement
Confused with this constantly. An escape opening lets a person out and has to be operable by hand. A smoke vent lets smoke out and operates automatically.
The escape requirement is on how wide does an escape rooflight need to be.
Ventilation is a third thing
Worth separating clearly. Comfort ventilation is about air quality and temperature, and it is measured and specified quite differently.
That is on how much ventilation does an opening rooflight give.
Can one unit do two jobs
Sometimes, and it is designed rather than assumed.
Certified vents are made that also serve as daily ventilation, and where that is wanted it is specified from the start.
Maintenance and testing
A duty rather than good practice. Smoke ventilation systems are tested and maintained on a schedule, and records are kept, which is a responsibility for whoever manages the building.
What it looks like on a roof
Much like any opening rooflight, and that is the difficulty.
A certified vent and a comfort opener can be visually similar, so the only reliable way to know what is on a building is the documentation rather than the appearance.
On a block, that paperwork sits with whoever manages it.
Getting the specification right at the outset
Cheaper than discovering it late. A vent specified from the fire strategy at design stage is an ordinary product order, and one discovered at completion means a unit replaced and a panel installed in a finished stairwell.
What we ask for
The required free area and the control arrangement, in writing.
With those two figures a certified unit can be specified and priced properly, and without them nobody can say whether a product is suitable.
What we say on an opening unit
We say plainly when a requirement is a smoke ventilation one, because it is a specialist specification and fitting a comfort opener where a certified vent was required is a serious thing to get wrong.
The whole picture is on the electric rooflight installation page.
Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.