On a deep single storey extension where the middle of the plan is dark, usually yes. A lantern collects light from several directions and lifts the ceiling, and the effect in a kitchen is out of proportion to the area of glass. Where the room is shallow, or the roof is barely visible, a flat rooflight often does the same job more quietly and for less.
What it actually gives you
Two things, and only one of them is light.
Faces looking in several directions collect daylight through the whole day rather than only overhead, and the structure rising above the ceiling gives the room height it did not have.
People notice the second more than they expect to.
Why the height matters
Because a single storey extension is usually low.
A rear extension ceiling sits at ordinary head height, and a lantern is the only element that lets the room go upward, which changes how a kitchen feels to stand in.
Light through the day
The difference from a flat pane. A flat rooflight is at its best when the sun is high. A lantern has a face pointing east in the morning and one pointing west in the evening, so the room brightens earlier and stays lit later.
Light on an overcast day
Where it is genuinely better and rarely mentioned.
Under a grey sky the brightest area is overhead, and a lantern presents several faces to it rather than one, so it gathers more of the little there is.
In a British winter that is most days.
What it costs against a flat rooflight
More, on every line. More glass than plan area, a taller kerb, more frame, and generally more making good, so a lantern is a step above an equivalent flat unit rather than an alternative at the same price.
Where the money goes is on how much does a roof lantern cost.

What it costs in heat
More than the same plan area of flat glass.
Because the sloping faces give a larger glazed area than the opening they cover, the heat loss is larger for the same hole in the roof.
The figures are on how much heat do you lose through a roof lantern.
What it costs in summer
The thing people regret when it is specified badly.
A lantern over a south facing kitchen collects a great deal of solar gain, and without solar control glass that room is uncomfortable in July.
How to avoid it is on will a roof lantern make the room too hot.
Where it is the wrong choice
A shallow extension with plenty of glazing already.
A room three metres deep with bifold doors across the back is not short of light, and a lantern there adds cost and heat loss for very little gain.
Where a flat rooflight is better
Where the roof is overlooked and the house is modern.
Seen from an upstairs window, a flat pane reads as a quiet rectangle and a lantern reads as a structure, and on a plain modern house the flat unit is often the more considered choice.
The comparison is on what is the difference between a roof lantern and a skylight.
Where a lantern is clearly right
A period house with a deep rear addition.
A Victorian back addition with a lantern over the kitchen is what those houses often had, and the shape belongs to the building in a way a flush pane does not.
What it does to a valuation
Something, and it is hard to isolate.
A bright kitchen sells a house and a dark one does not, and a lantern is one of the things buyers photograph, though nobody can put a figure on it honestly.
What it does to how a room is used
The argument that actually persuades people. A dark middle of a plan is where nothing happens. Light it and the table moves there, and the room stops being a corridor with a kitchen at one end.

Against two flat rooflights
A fair comparison and often close. Two flat units spaced across a room light it more evenly, cost less and lose less heat. One lantern gives more height and more directional light.
Which wins depends on whether the ceiling is the point.
Against a bigger door opening
Worth thinking about before deciding. Wider doors light the back of a room brilliantly and the middle of it hardly at all, which is why a lantern and a door opening solve different problems.
Maintenance over the years
Modest, and there is some. A lantern is above a roof and collects what the wind brings, so it wants clearing periodically, and the frame finish wants rinsing near the coast.
That is on do roof lanterns need cleaning.
Whether it will leak
Not when the kerb is right, and that is the whole of it.
Lanterns very rarely fail as products, and the failures that happen are at the junction with a badly built or poorly weathered upstand.
The detail is on do roof lanterns leak.
The specification that makes it worth it
Three items and they are all decided at order.
Solar control glass, slim frame sections, and a properly insulated kerb. Those three separate a lantern people love from one they complain about.
What we say on a lantern
We say when a room does not need one, because on a shallow extension with a large door opening a lantern is money spent on a problem the room does not have.
The whole picture is on the roof lantern installation page.
Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.