Sun Tunnel Installation

Rigid against flexible tunnel runs

A sun tunnel is a dome on the roof, a tube through the roof space, and a diffuser in the ceiling. The tube comes in two forms and the choice between them decides how much light arrives, which is the whole point of the product.

The two forms

Rigid is a straight metal tube, highly polished on the inside, supplied in sections that join to make up the length. Bends are made with purpose made elbow sections at defined angles.

Flexible is a corrugated or concertina tube with a reflective lining, which bends to any shape and route.

Both do the same job. They do it to very different standards, and the difference is larger than most people expect.

Why rigid performs better

Because light travelling down a tube is bouncing off the wall, repeatedly, and every bounce loses a little.

A rigid tube has a smooth, highly polished, near mirror surface. Light arriving at a shallow angle skims along it with very few bounces and each one is efficient.

A flexible tube has a corrugated surface. Light hits the ridges at all sorts of angles, bounces more often and more randomly, and each bounce is off a less perfect surface. The losses compound along the run.

Which means over the same distance a rigid tube delivers substantially more light, and the gap widens as the run gets longer.

The comparison

Rigid against flexible
Rigid Flexible
Light delivered Substantially more Less, and worse over distance
Route Straight, with defined bends Any route, any angle
Obstructions Worked around with elbows Simply bent past
Installation More set out, more time Quicker
Long runs The only sensible choice Falls away badly
Cost Higher Lower

The default is rigid

On any run where a straight or nearly straight route exists, rigid is specified and the extra cost is worth paying.

The reason is that a sun tunnel is bought for one thing, which is the amount of daylight arriving in a room that has none. Specifying the version that delivers less of it, to save a modest amount, is spending money on a compromised version of the only benefit.

Where somebody is choosing between a flexible tunnel and no tunnel, flexible is obviously better. Where the choice is between the two tubes, rigid is the answer unless the route forbids it.

When flexible is the right answer

Genuinely, and there are cases.

  • A route with several changes of direction that rigid elbows cannot follow.
  • A congested roof space where a tank, services and structure leave only a winding path.
  • A short run where the loss is small in absolute terms.
  • A retrofit into a finished ceiling where access is limited and a rigid tube cannot be assembled in place.
  • Where the alternative is no tunnel at all.
The roof dome of a sun tunnel installed on a tiled slope with its flashing dressed into the courses, seen from ladder height
Bends cost light in both

Bends cost light in both

The point that decides most routes, and it applies to rigid tubes as much as flexible ones.

Every change of direction turns light back on itself and adds bounces. A run with two bends delivers noticeably less than a straight run of the same length, and a run with several is losing a great deal before it reaches the ceiling.

Which means the design objective is a straight run, or as close to it as the roof space allows, rather than a clever route. Where a bend is unavoidable, one shallow bend is far better than two sharp ones.

How much each bend actually costs is set out on the reflectivity page.

Straightness beats shortness

A useful rule that runs against intuition.

Given a choice between a short run with two bends and a longer straight one, the straight run frequently delivers more light. Length costs light gradually; bends cost it in steps.

So the routing question is not where the shortest path is but where the straightest one is, and moving the roof dome a metre to achieve a straight run is usually worth doing.

Rigid elbows

How a rigid system handles a change of direction, and it is more capable than people assume.

Purpose made elbow sections allow defined angles, and adjustable ones allow a range. Two elbows can offset a run sideways, which is how a tunnel gets past a purlin or steps across from a roof position to a ceiling position.

What rigid cannot do is follow a winding path. Where three or more changes of direction are needed, the run is either flexible or it is redesigned.

Hybrid runs

The answer that is frequently best and is rarely offered.

A rigid tube for the long straight portion, with a short flexible section at one end to negotiate an obstruction or to make the final connection.

That gives the efficiency of rigid over the distance that matters and the adaptability of flexible where it is needed. Most manufacturers support it, and it is worth asking about rather than accepting an all-or-nothing choice.

Diameter matters more than tube type

Worth saying because it puts the choice in proportion.

A larger diameter tube delivers considerably more light than a smaller one, and the effect is larger than the difference between rigid and flexible at the same size.

So the order of decisions is diameter first, then tube type, then route. A flexible tunnel of generous diameter can outperform a narrow rigid one, and the best answer is generally a generous rigid tube on a straight run.

Diameter selection has its own page.

The inside of a trussed rafter roof space, W shaped webs and punched metal plate joints clearly visible at the intersections, daylight from a gable vent
What the inside surface is

What the inside surface is

The component doing the work, and it varies between products more than the rigid-or-flexible distinction suggests.

Rigid tubes are lined with a highly specular reflective material, and manufacturers publish a reflectivity figure. Small differences in that figure compound over a run, because the light bounces many times.

Which means two rigid tubes of the same diameter and length can perform differently, and the published reflectivity is the number to compare rather than the description. A supplier who cannot quote it is describing a product rather than specifying one.

How each is installed

The practical difference, and it explains the cost gap.

A rigid run is set out: the dome position and the diffuser position are established, the route is checked for clearance, the sections are cut and assembled to length, and the joints are made and sealed. It takes longer and it is a considered installation.

A flexible run is cut to length and bent into place. It is quicker, and it is also easier to do badly: a flexible tube left slack, sagging between its ends, has effectively added length and bends nobody designed.

The commonest flexible installation error

Worth naming because it accounts for most disappointing flexible tunnels.

The tube is cut generously and left with slack in it, so it hangs in a curve or two between the roof and the ceiling. Every centimetre of that slack is extra length, and every dip is a bend.

A flexible tunnel should be pulled taut and supported along its run, so it is as straight and as short as the route allows. Done properly it performs respectably; left slack it delivers a fraction of what it should.

Joints and sealing

A requirement on both and it matters for more than light.

Joints between rigid sections are taped or sealed so that the tube is continuous, because a gap admits dust which settles on the reflective surface and lowers it permanently, and because the tube passes through a cold roof space where air movement matters.

On a flexible tube the connections at each end are the equivalent. A poorly made connection at the dome is a route for dust and for moisture.

What ages

Very little, and knowing what little is useful.

The reflective surface does not wear, because nothing touches it. What reduces it over decades is dust settling on the inside of the tube, which is why the joints being sealed matters and why the run is kept as short as the route allows.

A flexible tube’s lining can be creased or damaged during installation, and a crease is a permanent loss at that point. Rigid sections are harder to damage in place.

Where the run passes through

A consideration that applies to both and is easy to overlook.

The tube crosses a cold roof space, so it is a cold surface in a warm building at the ceiling end and a cold one at the roof end. Insulating the run, and sealing it at the ceiling, is what prevents condensation forming inside and prevents warm air being lost up it.

That is covered on the condensation page and it applies to rigid and flexible equally.

Marine grade stainless steel fixings and a coated aluminium frame section laid out on a roof membrane before installation, salt haze in the air
Fire and compartments

Fire and compartments

Where the tube crosses a floor or a wall doing a fire resisting job, the penetration has to be made good so the compartment still performs.

On a straightforward tunnel from a roof into a room below it, that does not arise. On a run that crosses from one part of a building into another, or in a flat, it does, and it is designed rather than improvised.

Supporting the run

A detail that decides whether a tube performs as designed and it is easy to skip in a roof space nobody sees.

A rigid run is supported so the sections stay in line and the joints stay closed. A tube pushed into place and left resting on a ceiling joist and a purlin sags at the joints, which opens them to dust and puts a slight kink where there should be a straight line.

A flexible run needs supporting along its length, not just at the ends, so it stays taut and straight rather than hanging in curves. Straps at intervals cost minutes and are the difference between a designed run and a tube somebody threaded through.

Retrofit into a finished ceiling

The situation that most often decides in favour of flexible, and it is worth thinking about before conceding.

Where the ceiling is finished and the only access is the roof space, a rigid run has to be assembled from above, working down a confined space, which is awkward and occasionally impossible. A flexible tube can be fed through.

Where there is reasonable roof space access, a rigid run is entirely feasible on a retrofit and it is what we would still specify. Where the space is a shallow void with no room to work, flexible is the honest answer rather than a compromise.

What to ask a supplier

  1. Rigid or flexible, and can a hybrid run be supplied?
  2. What is the published reflectivity of the tube lining?
  3. What diameters are available and what does each deliver over my run length?
  4. What elbow angles are available, and how many bends does my route need?
  5. What is the maximum run length for the system?

What the visit covers on a sun tunnel

We survey the roof space and look for a straight route before choosing a tube type, because that decision usually makes itself once the route is known. We specify rigid wherever a straight or near straight run exists, propose a hybrid where an obstruction sits at one end, and pull a flexible tube taut and support it where flexible is genuinely the answer.

The tube is the product. A rigid one on a straight run delivers what a sun tunnel is bought for, and a slack flexible one round three bends does not.

Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.

Get a fixed quote

Get a fixed quote

Tell us about the roof. We will tell you the price.

A survey costs you nothing and there is no obligation attached to it. We look at the roof build-up, the exposure and the opening, and give you one fixed figure, not an estimate that moves once work starts.

If your rooflight is leaking now, say so and we will prioritise the survey.

  • Fixed price, confirmed in writing
  • 10-year workmanship guarantee
  • Installed to current Building Regulations
  • Your roof is never left open overnight
Call Get a fixed quote