Structural openings a lantern needs, and when a steel is unavoidable
Every roof lantern begins with a hole cut in a roof, and the hole is the part of the job that decides the cost. A lantern that sits inside what can be trimmed with ordinary carpentry is one kind of job. One that needs a designed beam is a different kind, and the step between them is a step rather than a gradient.
This page sets out where that step falls and how to find out which side of it your roof is on.
What the deck is doing before you cut it
A flat roof deck spans between supports on joists at regular centres, usually 400mm or 600mm apart. Each joist carries its share of the roof build-up, the covering, any imposed load such as snow, and the weight of anybody who goes up there.
The load path is simple and continuous: covering to deck, deck to joists, joists to wall plates, wall plates to walls, walls to foundations. Cutting a joist interrupts that path, and the load it was carrying has to go somewhere else.
Trimming, and what it actually is
Trimming is the ordinary answer, and it is what most lantern openings need.
The joists crossing the opening are cut, and two trimmers are fixed across the ends of the cut joists, spanning between the two nearest uncut joists on either side. The load from the cut joists transfers into the trimmers, along them, and into the neighbouring joists, which now carry more than they did.
Those neighbouring joists are frequently doubled to take the extra. The whole assembly is timber, it is fixed with joist hangers and structural screws, and it is ordinary carpentry that needs no engineer.
Where trimming stops working
Trimming works while three things stay within limits.
- The trimmer has to span the opening without excessive deflection, and a timber trimmer of conventional depth has a practical limit.
- The neighbouring joists have to take their own load plus the share transferred to them, without being overloaded.
- The connections have to carry the concentrated loads at the trimmer ends, which get large quickly as the opening widens.
Widen the opening and all three get worse at once. At some width the trimmer would need to be so deep that it does not fit in the roof zone, and at that point the opening becomes a designed one.

There is no universal figure
People want a number, and the honest answer is that the number depends on the roof.
| Factor | Pushes toward trimming | Pushes toward a designed beam |
|---|---|---|
| Joist span | Short span | Long span |
| Joist depth and centres | Deep joists at close centres | Shallow joists at 600mm |
| Opening width across the joists | Narrow, a few joists cut | Wide, many joists cut |
| Position of the opening | Near a support | Mid span, where deflection is worst |
| What else the roof carries | Nothing above | A tank, plant, a terrace, a wall over |
| Roof build-up weight | Light single ply | Asphalt, ballast, a green roof |
As a general shape, a lantern occupying a modest proportion of a rear extension deck, positioned sensibly and cutting a small number of joists, will trim. One approaching the full width of the deck will not. We would rather measure it than assert a number that is wrong on half the roofs it is applied to.
When a structural engineer is needed
An engineer is needed whenever the opening stops being routine, and the honest signals are these.
- The opening is wide relative to the joist span, so the trimmers are carrying a great deal.
- Anything sits over the opening: a wall, a first floor, a step in the building, plant on the roof.
- The existing structure is unclear, which is common where a roof has been altered before.
- The roof is not conventional joists, for example a flat roof formed on trussed rafters or on a beam and block deck.
- Building Control asks for calculations, which they may on any of the above.
An engineer’s design is a cost and a lead time, and it is a small proportion of a job it applies to. It is also the only thing that makes a wide opening defensible, and it produces calculations that Building Control can accept rather than an opinion they cannot.
What a designed opening uses
Steel
A rolled steel section, sized by the engineer, sitting on padstones or bearing plates at each end. It is the strongest option for the depth available, which matters where the roof zone is shallow. It is heavy, it usually needs several people or a lift to get in, and on a coastal site it needs proper protective treatment.
Flitch beam
A steel plate sandwiched between two timbers and bolted through. It gives much of the strength of steel with the handling and fixing convenience of timber, and it goes in through a doorway in pieces where a steel cannot. Frequently the practical answer in a terrace with no side access.
Engineered timber
Glulam or LVL, which are timber products with far more predictable strength than sawn timber. They span further than sawn joists, they are light enough to handle, and they look like timber if they are going to be visible. Depth is the constraint.
Bearings are half the design
A beam is only as good as what its ends sit on, and this is the part that gets missed on site more often than the beam size.
The load that was spread along a wall now arrives at two points. Those points need adequate bearing length, and they need something under them capable of taking a concentrated load, which usually means a padstone or a spread bearing rather than a beam end sitting on cut brickwork.
Where the load lands over a window or a door opening below, the lintel there has to be checked as well, because it was never designed for a point load in the middle of it.
Deflection, and why stiffness beats strength here
A beam over a lantern opening is almost never sized by strength. It is sized by how much it is allowed to sag.
Timber and steel are both strong enough to hold up a domestic roof at sizes well below what actually gets specified. What decides the section is the deflection limit, which is a fraction of the span, and it exists because a structure that sags visibly is unacceptable even when it is perfectly safe.
On a lantern opening there is a second reason to care. The kerb sits on the trimmed opening and the lantern sits on the kerb, and a made to size aluminium frame does not tolerate movement underneath it. A trimmer that deflects under snow load takes the kerb with it, and the kerb takes the frame. That is how a unit that was square on the day of installation stops being square two winters later, and it shows up as a seal that has started to leak at one corner.

Trussed rafters, and the roof that cannot simply be cut
Most of what is above applies to a flat roof on joists. A pitched roof built with trussed rafters is a different case and it is worth flagging because the estates across Durrington, Rustington, Southwater and Burgess Hill are full of them.
A trussed rafter is an engineered component. Every member in it is in tension or compression as part of a designed system, and cutting any one of them destroys that system. It is not like cutting a joist, where the load has an obvious alternative path. There is no equivalent of trimming that can be done by eye.
What that means in practice is that openings between trusses are straightforward at the width the truss centres allow, and openings wider than that need a designed solution from the outset. On those roofs the product decision follows the structure rather than the other way round, which is covered on the trussed rafter page.
Getting it in, on a terrace
A great many of the houses we work on around Worthing, Hove and Littlehampton are terraced with no side access, and that constrains the structural solution as much as the engineering does.
A four metre steel cannot be carried through a Victorian hall and up a staircase. Options are to bring it over the roof with a lift, to close a road for a crane, or to use a flitch or engineered timber solution that arrives in handleable pieces. The engineer will usually design to whichever is possible if they are told the constraint, and they will design a steel if nobody mentions it.
That is a survey question, and asking it before the design rather than after saves a redesign.
Party walls
Where a beam bears into a party wall, or where the work involves cutting into it, the Party Wall etc. Act applies. That means notice served on the adjoining owner, with a statutory period for them to respond.
It is a matter of timing rather than difficulty. Most neighbours consent, and the process is well established. What it is not is something to discover two weeks before the work is booked, because the notice periods are fixed and cannot be compressed.
Building Control
Forming a new opening in a roof is notifiable under the Building Regulations. Structural alteration is exactly the kind of work the system exists for, and it is not a formality to be skipped.
We notify Building Control where the work is notifiable and the completion certificate comes to you. That certificate is the document a buyer’s solicitor asks for when the house is sold, and its absence on structural work is a genuine problem at that point rather than a paperwork nuisance.

Opening up, and what is found
Roofs are rarely built exactly as drawn, and older ones have frequently been altered.
What we find on opening up, in rough order of frequency: joists at different centres from those assumed, a previous opening trimmed badly or not at all, decayed timber where water has been getting in at a detail, and services running through the zone the trimmers need to occupy.
None of these is unusual and all of them change the work. We flag what we find rather than springing it, and we quote the known work with the unknowns named, which is the only honest way to price a roof nobody has seen inside.
Two smaller openings instead of one
Where the structural answer is expensive, it is worth asking whether the daylight could be got a different way.
Two modest lanterns, each trimmed between joists, spaced along a long extension, deliver more even light than one large one and may avoid a designed beam entirely. The trade is more perimeter detailing and two openings to waterproof rather than one, which is real but is usually the smaller cost.
This is worth raising early, because it is a decision about the roof rather than about the product, and it stops being available once the structure is designed around a single opening.
The sequence, start to finish
- Survey, establish the structure, the span, the centres and what sits above.
- Decide trimmed or designed, and where designed, get the engineer in before anything else.
- Check the access route for whatever the design needs.
- Serve any party wall notice, allowing for the statutory period.
- Notify Building Control.
- Form the opening, with the roof made secure at the end of each day.
- Build the kerb to the measured opening, level on top and square.
- Order the unit to the kerb, not to the drawing.
What we open
We open up and look at the structure rather than assuming it, and we say early whether a job trims or needs designing, because that is the number that moves. Where an engineer is needed we say so before you have chosen a unit. We never leave a roof open overnight, which matters more on a roof that has been cut.
The lantern is a product. The opening is the job.
Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.