Energy Efficient Rooflights

Are rooflights and skylights energy efficient?

A rooflight is not an energy saving measure and it is not the liability people fear. It loses more heat than the insulated roof it replaced, admits useful solar gain in winter, and reduces the need for artificial light. Well specified and well installed, the net effect on a domestic house is small. Badly installed, it is not.

The honest ledger

Three entries, and the first is the largest.

Fabric heat loss increases, because glass performs several times worse than an insulated roof. Winter solar gain increases, which offsets part of it. Lighting energy falls, modestly.

Set against the whole house, the net is a small number in the wrong direction, for a room that is transformed.

Why glass loses more than roof

Because it is doing a different job and there is no arguing with the physics.

A modern insulated roof performs several times better than even a good glazed unit, so replacing a square metre of one with the other increases the loss through that square metre.

The comparison with a wall window is on does a rooflight lose more heat than a window.

The installation matters more than the product

The point worth taking away, and it is where the real losses are.

A well specified unit fitted with insulation stopping short of the frame loses heat around itself rather than through itself, and that loss appears in no datasheet.

Insulation carried right up to the frame with the vapour control layer sealed to it is what makes the calculated performance the actual performance.

Air leakage

The loss that is invisible and frequently larger than the glazing difference.

An old rooflight leaks air around its frame, through a failed seal, and through the gap somebody filled with foam twenty years ago. That is heat leaving continuously.

A new unit correctly sealed removes it, and on a draughty old installation that single change is worth more than the glass specification.

A pale kitchen lit only by a large rooflight on an overcast day, the light even across the worktops, no artificial lighting on, no people
Replacing an old unit is an improvement

Replacing an old unit is an improvement

The case that applies to most of our work, and it is worth saying.

A single skin plastic dome or an early double glazed unit performs several times worse than a current product, and its sealing detail is generally absent.

So a replacement is a genuine gain rather than a cost, sometimes a substantial one.

Winter solar gain

The entry on the other side, and it is real.

A south facing rooflight admits solar energy on bright winter days, at the season when it is most useful, offsetting part of the fabric loss over a heating season.

It is not enough to make glass better than insulation. It does mean the net effect is smaller than the U-value alone suggests.

Lighting energy

Modest, and it is the entry most often overstated.

A dark internal room lit artificially through the day uses electricity that daylight replaces. In a windowless hall or bathroom that is a genuine saving.

Against a heating bill it is a small number, and we would not build a case on it.

Summer, and the other direction

Where a rooflight can genuinely cost energy in a house with cooling.

Solar gain that is useful in December is not in July, and a room that overheats is a room somebody may cool mechanically.

Specifying the glass by aspect is what prevents that, and it is on what is solar control glass.

What the numbers actually are

Worth putting in proportion rather than in isolation.

One domestic rooflight is a square metre or two of a building envelope measured in hundreds. The difference between a good unit and an excellent one, over a season, is small.

The difference between a good installation and a poor one is considerably larger.

Where it stops being small

Two cases where the arithmetic changes. A lantern or a run of units, where the glazed area is no longer trivial against the roof it sits in. And a poorly detailed installation, where the loss is around the unit rather than through it.

A warm edge spacer bar at the corner of a sealed glazing unit seen very close, the desiccant perforations and the depth of the seal legible
What an EPC will say

What an EPC will say

A modelled answer rather than a measured one.

Adding glazed area to a roof generally moves a modelled fabric figure slightly the wrong way, and on a typical domestic rooflight the effect on a rating is small.

The detail is on does a rooflight affect an EPC.

What actually moves a heating bill

Worth saying, because customers ask us to justify a rooflight on energy grounds and it does not.

Loft insulation, draught proofing, and heating controls that work are all cheaper than a rooflight and all do considerably more.

A rooflight is bought for daylight, and that is a good enough reason without an energy argument propped underneath it.

Doing it during other work

Where the energy argument does point somewhere useful.

Where a roof is being insulated or recovered anyway, fitting a rooflight at that point means the insulation and the air barrier are designed around it rather than cut into afterwards.

That is materially better than the same unit added later.

What we will not claim

Plainly, because plenty of people do. A rooflight will not reduce a heating bill. It can be close to neutral, properly specified and properly installed, in exchange for a room that is transformed.

That is a fair trade and it is not an energy efficiency measure.

What we always specify on the glazing

We specify the glass by aspect, detail the insulation and the air barrier properly at the frame, and correct the roof insulation while the roof is open where it is inadequate.

The whole picture is on the energy efficient rooflights page.

Thinking about this job? We survey across Worthing, West Sussex and the South Downs and give you a fixed price before any work starts, with a 10-year workmanship guarantee.

Get a fixed quote

Get a fixed quote

Tell us about the roof. We will tell you the price.

A survey costs you nothing and there is no obligation attached to it. We look at the roof build-up, the exposure and the opening, and give you one fixed figure, not an estimate that moves once work starts.

If your rooflight is leaking now, say so and we will prioritise the survey.

  • Fixed price, confirmed in writing
  • 10-year workmanship guarantee
  • Installed to current Building Regulations
  • Your roof is never left open overnight
Call Get a fixed quote